Special Cake for a “Picky Palate”

filed under: Chocolate Cakes on August 20, 2012

Have you ever met Jenny?  She is the genius force behind the amazing blog, Picky Palate.

And… she is having a baby!


Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
Prep Time
15 mins
Cook Time
35 mins
Total Time
50 mins
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
Servings: 8 servings
Author: Amanda Rettke
  • 36 ounces of cookie dough I use the Nestle tub
  • 14 -15 Double Stuff Oroes
  • 2 cups Buttercream
  1. In a well prepared 8inch cake pan, place half of your cookie dough. Press down so that it is a flat layer.

  2. Starting in the center, place Oreo's flat on top of cookie dough. Press down remaining cookie dough over Oreo layer.

  3. In an oven heated to 350, bake for 25-35 minutes. At 25 min. I placed an aluminum foil ring around the edge of the pan so the cookie edges would not burn, and then watched closely.

  4. Remove from oven when center is no longer shiny.
  5. Let cool and cover in buttercream.



oreo chocolate chip cookie cake

Well, did you know that sweet Jenny INVENTED the Oreo stuffed chocolate chip cookie?  You’ve seen it everywhere right… that glorious creation of a chocolate chip cookie with an entire Oreo hidden in the center?  Jenny was the Original!  Isnt that cool?

So I decided to make a cake that was as unique and as fun as she is.  Which is no easy challenge!

The outside I based on her adorable blog design.


The border is made to mimic Jenny’s pretty scalloped blog header.

The rattle is a “baby-fied”  interpretation of her knife, fork, and spoon logo.

oreo chocolate chip cake

And the inside…

oreo chocolate chip cookie cake

A chocolate chip cookie Oreo stuffed Cake!  You totally saw that comin right?  I posted a quick “recipe” for this cake below, but be sure to check out Jenny’s Original Recipe to make mouth watering Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies!

oreo stuffed chocolate chip cake

oreo chocolate chip cookie cake title

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  • Dina says:

    Looks divine and so sweet of you to make for your friend. YUM!

  • Kaius says:

    You have an amazing blog. I wish I could eat everything you make.

    I love the cookie dough cake. I’m going to ask my mummy to make it for me.

  • Christina Main says:

    Ha! Oh my word…this “cake” cracks me up. Looks yummy, friend!!

  • ihuoma ken ohiorenoya says:

    Although I do not no Jenny,I am sure this will warm her heart cos I cracked a huge smile as soon as I sighted the inside of her cake.From what I saw on her blog,this cake interprets her well.You must be a GENIUS.Couldn’t resist commenting.God bless you all for organizing this for her.

  • Holiday Baker Man says:

    Very Cool!

  • tanya1234 says:

    luv it it goes with my diet lol thankx

  • Bellenza Bistro says:

    Absolutely ingenious…and delicious, for sure!

  • Jocelyn @BruCrew Life says:

    That is the coolest “cake” ever!!! I love how you customized it to match Jenny’s blog header…how cute!! You always have the best cakes here!!!

  • pressedolives says:

    I am making a cowgirl boot cake. Here is my question: do you think if I make this cake in a 9×13 pan (of course the recipe will be doubled) can I easily cut out from a template into the cake?? Or will the oreos and cookie layer make it hard to cut a design? Thanks for your help!!

    • Amanda says:

      I would just cut it IMMEDIATELY out of he oven. The longer it sets the harder it would be to cut. Have fun!

  • Sue {munchkin munchies} says:

    This cake is the awesome-est! 🙂

  • Heidi says:

    I hate to be the one to say it, but that is positively disgusting. Oreos belong nowhere in any baked product. How dare you call yourself a baker?

    By the way, any good shorbread recipe has either cornstarch or rice flour in addition to the AP flour.

    I am a baker. I studied the art and practice it.

    • Amanda says:

      Hi Heidi! Thank you so much for your honest feedback. I started my blog, i am baker, as an offshoot to my original blog, i am mommy. And while I feel confident in saying “I AM MOMMY!” I am often hesitant to declare I am baker. I have questioned my choice in blog titles many times! I am not trained, I just bake things I like. I have so much respect for those folks so ARE trained, as I know how difficult it is. Kudos to you! So sorry if my blog is displeasing to you. I promise I will try to work harder at the technical side of baking. Thanks, and have a great day!

  • Paula says:

    I’m doing this! Looks incredibly good!

  • greenturtle8 says:

    Whaou ! Super nice inspired cake !
    You dis a great job, i’d love to taste this !

  • James says:

    I live in Scotland. When we want to bake a cake in the UK we use things like flour, eggs and butter. In the US you buy a tub of cookie dough and throw in some biscuits. Why not just buy a cake? A cake baked ‘from scratch’ has a home baked taste and has much less addatives. I bake a fruit cake where you simmer the fruit, sugar and butter in a pan, allow to cool and then add the flour and eggs. You have to be in the kitchen for a total of less than 15 minutes. I know that you are trying to save busy people time but you end up with a ‘processed’ cake which will always be inferior to home baked cakes.

    • Amanda says:

      HI James! I totally understand what you are saying and completely support it. 🙂

  • Becca from ItsYummi! says:

    What a perfect treat for Jenny! Great job, Amanda!

  • Andrea says:

    Hi, Amanda. My family does NOT like store bought cookie dough. Do you have any idea how many batches (approx) of Toll House cookie dough I would have to make to equal the 36 oz tub?

    • Amanda says:

      I think it would be two full recipes. Hope that helps! Be blessed!

  • Jake Ryan says:

    Oh wow this looks incredible. I need it right now!!!

  • Laura says:

    Hi, I came across this as a great option for my father-in-law’s birthday who loves cookies and Oreos. I won’t have much time and was wondering if you knew how well this would keep frozen so I could make it about a week in advance?

  • I Am Baker Logo

    Brand new recipes that people find kinda acceptable.