Remember this little thing?


You guys rock! You totally embraced my inability to count calories! *happy sigh* Don’t think I could love ya more.

Well, I am delighted to show you how to make this bad boy.

I started out with this white cake recipe. Its a bit more dense due to the fact the I used regular flour and not cake flour. I needed something sturdy to stand up to the powerful punch of the insane amount of chocolate on this cake. But if you prefer a light, airy cake I would definitely just try your favorite white cake recipe. (that or use cake flour in the one I used)

What you will need:

One white cake (I used six inch pans for a nice thick cake)

2 boxes chocolate covered cherries

1 bottle hot fudge (or make your own!)

1 package of Oreo crumbs (you can also make these on your own but *speaking from experience* I would just buy the pre-crumbed crumbs. And that concludes my technical mumbo jumbo for the day.)

Frosting of choice. I used a creamy vanilla. I like it, but am still perfecting it so no recipe yet! Sorry! Here is a sweet buttercream if you are so inclined.


Bake cakes.

Place a few pieces of wax paper around the base of your cake stand. This is pretty important!

This cake could be a big mess if you skip this step. Trust me on this.

Set one cake round on cake stand and use about 1/4 cup of frosting for center layer.

Add chocolate covered cherries.

One for the cake, one for your belly.


Repeat until cake is covered. Ok maybe you dont have to follow the instructions verbatim, cause that would mean you just ate 15 chocolate covered cherries and that is really just ridiculous!

Why would I suggest such a thing?!?!?!


You could stop right here cause I mean… really. Hello delicious. But remember how much we love calories? Bring on the frosting!


I simply took a knife and spread frosting over the cherries and in between, then smoothed it out.

Right into the freezer for at least 30 minutes! I really want this frosting layer to set up and be study for our next layer of cake.


Remove from freezer and place remaining layer of cake on top.

Cover with crumb coat.


I would get it smooth but it certainly doesn’t have to be neat! The next layer is where we get messy.

Put back in freezer for 30 min. or more, or fridge for at least an hour.


Take your hot fudge (that should not be hot temperature wise!) and poured it over the cake until every inch was covered.

(Please pretend there is a picture here of an Oreo crumb covered cake… whoops!)

I then took Oreo crumbs and just smashed them into the cake. This got pretty messy.. so when I was done I took a fondant smoother and made a nice, clean, flat surface.


I put it right in the fridge to set up before removing the wax strips around the base. Getting the crumbs to really adhere to the hot fudge and frosting is important for a nice clean cut.


Then put a little dollop of frosting and added a cherry on top.

Fun and easy and oh so delicious!

You can obviously play with this cake and have fun with the design and ingredients… but one thing I would not change is the chilling part. You really want those layers to get sturdy and stay that way!

You can serve it chilled or at room temp. When it is at room temp. the chocolate covered cherries ooze that glorious creamy cherry filling over the cake and add such fantastic flavor!!

Be sure to let me know if you try it!

Share with your friends!

Categorized in:

Related Recipes

Meet Amanda Rettke

Amanda Rettke is the creator of I Am Baker, and the bestselling author of Surprise Inside Cakes: Amazing Cakes for Every Occasion – With a Little Something Extra Inside.Over the course of her 15+ year blogging adventure, she has been featured in and collaborated with the Food Network, New York Times, LA Times, Country Living Magazine, People Magazine, Epicurious, Brides, Romantic Homes, life:beautiful, Publishers Weekly, The Daily Mail, Star Tribune, The Globe and Mail, DailyCandy, YumSugar, The Knot, The Kitchn, and Parade, to name a few.

Reader Comments

  1. Oh for heaven’s sake! How do you come up with such devilishly delicious ideas?! Pure evil, yes, pure sweet evil…… I’m gaining weight just looking at the photograph. Chocolate covered cherries are one of my favorites but I only let myself have them around Christmas time, so this recipe will be my new cake for the holidays. Thanks for sharing!

  2. OMG. This cake. OMG.

    I don’t bake a lot, but I had forgotten that it was my roommate’s birthday & I was broke, so I had to do something special! He loooooooves Oreos. 🙂

    Since I was rushed, I just used what I had, or could find in the first store I went to, lol. I used a store-bought red velvet cake mix & cream cheese frosting. They didn’t have cherries, but they had chocolate-covered blueberries – this did not make me sad. No Oreo crumbs, either, but doing it in the food processor was easy.

    I only have 8″ pans, too, so that’s what I used. I told myself right away “ok, I’m not going to stress about making it look perfect like in a food blog” … but you know, it didn’t turn out too bad! Certainly great for a small birthday get together.

    You can see it here:

    It didn’t cut so easy because in addition to the freezing you suggest here, I had put the berries in the freezer while the cake was baking. Don’t do that, lol.

  3. I might have to try this cake because I super adore Cellas, but maybe I could suggest a chocolate ganache instead of hot fudge? Ganache is so easy to make, and it leaves such a perfect, glossy presentation–no need for oreo cookie coat!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.