Christmas Surprise Inside Cake

filed under: Rose + Rosette Cakes · Surprise Inside Cakes on December 3, 2013

I had no intention of sharing this cake.

Christmas Surprise Inside Cake #surpriseinside

Everything that could go wrong, did.

The multi-colored roses are oddly resembling a pile of mush.  The touch of green leaves is a more of a massive green undergrowth and has a life of its own.

Surprise Inside Cake!

And the inside… well.  Lets just say that was not my best work.

Its completely tilted over.

Christmas JOY Surprise Inside Cake #surpriseinside

Why on earth would it do that?  Maybe because I used the wrong cookie cutters when preparing my cake and they were too tall for the pan so I had to improvise and create a “wall” around the cake with parchment so when I poured the extra batter over the letters it wouldn’t spill out the sides which didn’t really work and the batter did spill out on all sides resembling a square mushroom that took 70 minutes to bake and ITS CROOKED.


This cake that I spent many hours dreaming about and baking and decorating was a total failure.

Christmas Surprise Inside Cake #surpriseinside

But then I shared this picture on Instagram with the caption, “Guess what I am up to.”  and the adorable @achewycookie said,

“Spreading some JOY!”

And I was humbled.  Because most people don’t care about the dumb details like I obsessively do.

They just feel loved and appreciated when someone makes them a cake.  As they should.

So here it is.  The cake that should have been something else but isn’t so it is what it is.

Merry Christmas. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  • Kimberly H says:

    I think it’s cute! I showed my husband and he said it is just in italics. 🙂

  • Christine Hill says:

    The letters aren’t tilted, they are in Italics!

  • bridget {bake at 350} says:

    I only WISH my mistakes were that adorable! Love the JOY and the roses!!!

  • Paula says:

    It’s beautiful and the titled Joy is perfect. Puts more emphasis on the meaning of the word.

  • Jules says:

    My dear Amanda, dun be too hard on yourself.
    You have already spreaded the joy around – crooked or not crooked. Beauty lies in the heart of the beholder and I simply LOVE your cakes! they never fail to inspire and make my day 🙂

  • Paula says:

    Oops, that should have read tilted.

  • Cat says:

    Straight up and down JOY is too rigid and boring. Tilted JOY on the other hand is FUN and… well, JOYful. Relax. It’s lovely and FUN!

  • Katy says:

    First, let me say that I absolutely love your cakes. But I had no idea where this photo had come from when I saw it on Pinterest, and I clicked it because I really thought the cake was piled with bacon. Delicious icing bacon.

    • Amanda says:

      LOL I can totally see it!

  • Megan {Country Cleaver} says:

    That is beyond fun!! We are always hardest on ourselves – but people know that love and light was put into it – and they appreciate that more than anything else. Plus, I’m sure it tasted AMAZING!!

  • Jessica says:

    I was raised by a mother who was a pastry perfectionist. When her creation failed (in her mind) my grandmother would say, “That’s alright dear, I’m sure it will taste just fine.” it became the family mantra for anything that went astray, from a flat tire to a bad spelling test, “That’s alright dear, I’m sure you taste just fine,” and the offender would be given a kiss.

    We just went to a wedding where the bride’s name was Joy. When the mother of the bride gave the toast, she told the groom, “Always keep your heart filled with Joy.” Thanks for the reminder that we should always keep our cakes filled with joy.

    • Amanda says:

      I love this.

  • Pamelaine says:

    I worry every time I bake something to give away. We all want to put our best effort and product out there. We all struggle sometimes. Thanks for sharing this beautiful cake. It gives us all inspiration!

  • collette says:

    It is tilted- it is in italics! I think it is beautiful and so much more than I could ever accomplish!

  • Rosanna says:

    I just continually *l.o.v.e.* your blog, Amanda + you and your sweet family!! ‘A little related story here for you: this past Sunday evening, my dear husband and I were in a local restaurant, where it was very quiet………… i.e., with it being the post-Thanksgiving Day Weekend, here in this college town. The only folks in the restaurant were me and my husband, sitting in a booth; plus a large party of maybe 7-8 Undergraduate Students and 2-3 parents, all sitting over at a big, rectangular, corner table. Anyway, we had all finished our meals, and were getting ready to leave, when Bobby Helms’ classic “Jingle Bell Rock” came on, i.e., over the Music System. The talkative/laughing students all just immediately stopped; then spontaneously launched into *SINGIN’*/*SWAYIN’* to the music, in their chairs or while standing………… and *TILTIN’ EVERY-WHICH-WAY WITH JOY*………… (i.e., just like the word “JOY” in your “Christmas Surprise-Inside Cake”………… is tiltin’, too)!! One of the girls then said, pointing, “Oh, wait, everybody, we’d better STOP”—-“we might be disturbing them,” (i.e., me and my husband)—-“over there!!” Since I’m a retired College Health Nurse………… the very SECOND, (haha!!), the girl finished saying that I said………… “No, we just LOVE it”………… “but ~ *S.*I.*N.*G.* ~ *L.*O.*U.*D.*E.*R.*!!!” And they all then very relievedly/gleefully/joyfully………… DID, (hahahahaha)!!

    This link, (directly Below), is for you and your readers to (turn the volume up and) sing along with, Amanda; and ~ while you’re doing so ~ just also go right ahead and sway/TILT to the music, too………… with *JOY*!!

    • Amanda says:

      What a wonderful story!! You have shared smiles and joy here today!! 🙂

      • Rosanna says:

        Thanks so much, Amanda—-‘glad you liked it!! A beautiful Traditional Irish Blessing** says, “Warm Be The Love That Surrounds You!!”………… and that’s my wish – during this Christmas Season – for you and your sweet family!!

        **Maybe I should also add, ” ‘Tilted Be The “JOY” That Surprises You,’ Inside Your Christmas Cake,” (haha!!)………… (And, Thankfully, Also ~ R.e.a.s.s.u.r.e.s. ~ Each Of Us That Our Work/Creativity/Selves Will Always Be Blessedly-Imperfect, Too)!!

        • Amanda says:

          lol Well said my friend!

  • Sarah R says:

    I just wanted to chime in with my two cents. When I read that you felt this was a ‘total failure’ my heart sank for you. I too am hyper critical of my own baking efforts – I baked it for two minutes too long and it’s dry, or I forgot to add sugar until just before it went in the oven and it ended up overmixed, etc. If I can stop the negative voice in my head, I can see that other people are so grateful that you took the time to make a baked treat by hand and share it with them! I think the tilted ‘joy’ gives it character and heart, and best of all, you can tell it is homemade because of the minor imperfections. You can learn from it and get the words straighter next time, but know that you are inspiring your readers. One of my favorite birthday cakes I ever made myself (ha!) was one I did covered in your rose technique (with blackberry frosting – yum!) Thanks for sharing!

  • Judy says:

    Love it! If you hadn’t said anything, I would think you meant to put JOY that way! It makes it look very JOYFUL! With a spring in its step! Thank you for sharing in your eyes, your less than perfect cake. It looks perfect to me.

  • Jennifer Erday says:

    Amanda, this cake couldn’t be more lovely! It is perfect in the very way we all are – created in love, unique in design and slightly tilted and off beat. You bring such “joy” to all us bakers….in every way, shape, form and now direction! Have a very blessed Christmas!! Thanks for another year of “Amandatastic-ness” (yes, that is totally a word!!!!) 🙂

  • Camila says:

    Just need to know how on God’s name did you get the letters in the cake.
    You are incredible.
    I’m a huge brazilian fan of yours.

  • Anne says:

    Are you kidding? I wish my cake mistakes looked this good. Your cakes are amazing!

  • Denise says:

    How exactly do you make the ”JOY” cake?