Some of the most common emails I get is “Can you do a tutorial on how to make a layer cake?” or “How do I get my crumb coat smooth?”
I would love to share the tips and tricks that I use!
This is the SUPER FAST and EASY version!
Use a good recipe. This can be a box mix or your favorite homemade recipe. You are looking for a cake the bakes up flat and even and moist and firm. Easy right? (This is my favorite chocolate cake recipe, it is perfect every time!)
Just in case your cake does not bake evenly, have no fear! You can simply level your cake. There are three easy ways to do that:
Use leveler or a long serrated knife to skim off the top dome part of your cake.
If your cake has risen above the edges of your cake pan, you can rest the knife on the edges of the pan and use the pan as your guide.
As soon as your cake is done baking, take a clean towel and lay it on top of your cake. Press gently and evenly. Tip: This only works if your cake is done baking! So make sure you test it.
Make sure all your layers are the same height.
Chill your layers before assembly. I find that working with a chilled or partially frozen cakes really helps. There is nothing worse than trying to assemble a layer cake and having it fall into pieces in your hands. And you totally know I am speaking from experience.
There are many methods to torting, or using frosting in between the layers of your cake. I like to do what is easiest and whatever method requires as few tools as necessary.
I just decide before hand how thick I want my layer to be and then use an appropriate amount of frosting. One-half cup is a nice thin layer on an 8in cake, but 1 cup of frosting is my go-to amount. I like frosting. Lots of it.
I typically use about a cup of frosting on a 6in as well as an 8in cake. I don’t recommend that. You be normal and use less on that 6in cake, ok?
Place your first layer on your cake stand. Put frosting on it and use a small offset spatula to make frosting an even layer.
Place your next layer on top. Some frosting should “spill out” the sides and that is exactly what you want. Repeat this process; frosting, layer of cake, frosting, layer of cake, until you have added all your layers.
When making a layer cake it is important to do a crumb coat.
A crumb coat is simply a thin layer of frosting applied to a cake. The crumb coat is intended to seal in crumbs, hence the name, crumb coat. Maybe too much frosting spilled out, or your layers may not be perfectly aligned, or maybe your cake is slightly lopsided. Doing a crumb coat is a great opportunity to fill in any problem areas.
Want to see how this cake turned out? It’s the New Years Eve Cake in my book, ‘surprise-inside cakes’!
Use an offset spatula. I put a dollop on top of the cake and then use the spatula to bring it down over the sides, making sure to get the frosting all the way to bottom.
If you have a rotating cake stand, you can place your spatula flat against the cake and slowly turn the stand. This will help smooth out the frosting and create an even coat.
You can also use a bench scraper and move around the cake. If you see any uneven spots, simply add more frosting to those areas and then repeat with the offset spatula or bench scraper.
Once your cake is covered in the crumb coat, I usually chill it for at least 10 minutes. I like the cake to settle and the frosting to set.
To decorate a cake, I start by putting a smooth layer of frosting on. This is done the same way as the crumb coat. Place a dollop on top of the cake and pull it down over the sides using an offset spatula.
To smooth out the sides, make sure the cake is covered in an even layer of frosting, then place spatula (or bench scraper) flat against side of cake. Slowly turning cake, smooth out layer of frosting until you have polished, even coat.
This step takes practice, so don’t be too hard on yourself if it doesn’t look perfect. Just keep at it until you are comfortable with how your cake looks!
Once you have the sides done, use your spatula to smooth out the top. Starting at the edge, gently press your spatula against the frosting and move in, towards the center of the cake. Repeat this around the entire cake until you have removed excess frosting.
You can use the small offset spatula to go around cake to make the top crisp and clean.
NOTE: If there are any dents or areas without enough frosting, simply add more frosting and then smooth out again. You can do this process as many times as needed!
I have also placed my cake stand directly on a rotating stand, and this helps me when smoothing out the edges.
I remember helping my mom make layered birthday cakes look more level than they actually were with extra frosting. That was in my teens. Haven’t made a layer cake as an adult, but when I do I’ll follow your tips. Thanks!
I have made layer cakes. I hate doing a crumb coating no matter what type of cake it is though. LOL I was wondering suggestions for car cakes for men. I’m trying to make a drag strip racing cake today, and I can’t think of things to make a ‘tree’ with. (the staging lights that tell the cars when to go not an actual tree :D) What are some things that are stiff enough to stand up, and support icing too- like a telephone pole with the parallel braces. Any ideas? Best I can think of right now would be pretzels, but the parallel lines get me.
Yes, I have made layered cakes before. I’d really love to win this!
I think this post was made for me! I just completely butchered a layer cake less than an hour ago. Such a mess. A sad, sad mess. Its tasty but so very ugly. In fact, I’m certain my two year old would have done a better job. Perhaps I’ll just say she did it anyways!? lol ugh..
Anyways, thank you for the tips and the chance to win such great tools! I hope I can eventually learn to frost a cake good enough to send in to your gallery. These tips are sure to get me started!
yes, I’ve made 2 layer cakes for my friend’s wedding! yum!
I’ve made a few layer cakes. My biggest struggle is getting them to sit straight on top of each other… I always end up having them be lopsided. I think it’s mostly because they get too warm. I’ll try them partially frozen.
Thanks for the tutorial. I have never made a layered cake. With your helpful instructions, I will try to make one. I will probably make it when everyone is asleep. If it is a disaster, I can dispose of the evidence without anyone judging me.
Yes, I have!
My boyfriend and I made one for a friend’s birthday, but it didn’t turn out too well. I can’t remember what he was doing, but he dropped one of the layers/cakes before we put filling in the center. I had to cut the remaining cake in half [and it wasn’t even either] so that we could still make a two layer cake with pudding in the middle.
I have made a few in my day… 🙂 None of them turned out as beautifully as yours did! But I am going to make lots of trial cakes before the big one… my wedding cake!!
Yes, I have! They do tend to get very crumbly and I had difficulty putting white frosting over the chocolate cake. I’m excited to try your suggestions about the crumb coat and also keeping the layers cold while icing!